← Selected workCase study · 7 min

1st Central · Conversion.com · 2021

Selling insurance from a brand nobody recognized.

In 2021, 1st Central was up against AXA and Admiral, and most people had never heard of it. Ouch. I had six weeks to redesign the quote journey around one moment: when someone decides whether to trust you with their car.

Role
Designer at the agency Conversion.com
Did
Research, UX, branding, visual design
With
Aaron from the UX agency Bunnyfoot on the mid-fidelity prototype, and 1st Central’s digital team
Timebox
6 weeks, research to dev handoff

Client projection

+£35m

in revenue over five years, from the client’s own model of the sales increase in a 50/50 A/B test

Add-on sales

10×

rise in sales of some add-ons (extra cover bought with a policy), according to the client's digital manager

1st Central

The redesigned quote journey
The 1st Central quote page on a phone, resting on gray concrete
Shipped 2021↗ Open any screen for a closer look

01 · The world

A small fish, a big pond, and six weeks.

1st Central had run small experiments with us for a while. In October 2021 they asked us to redesign their most valuable pages, the quote journey, and give the brand an identity while we were at it.

The catch: six weeks from kickoff to developer handoff. So Aaron at Bunnyfoot built the clickable prototype while I ran research and the final designs in parallel.

Wk 1Wk 2Wk 3Wk 4Wk 5Wk 6
Research
Wireframes
Mid-fi prototype
Design explorations
High-fidelity designs
Dev handoff
MeAaron, BunnyfootTogether

We overlapped the work on purpose. Research was feeding into the wireframes before it was finished.

02 · What was broken

Every product had its own journey.

Each product had its own version of the quote journey. That made it expensive to maintain and impossible to experiment on, and it looked its age.

The old journey had dense quote information and different layouts for each product.FIG. 01
01

Diverging journeys

Each product had its own flow, so every content update and every experiment had to be built three times.

02

Content nobody read

Pages used paragraphs where a line would do. People skimmed or skipped whole sections instead of engaging with them.

03

A UI that read as risky

When people don't know a brand, a dated design makes it look riskier. It gives them a reason to go back to the price comparison site.

So the goals were

  1. Earn trust fastMake someone confident buying from a name they had never heard of.
  2. One shared platformOne set of pages that is easy to add content to, adapt for each product, and experiment on.
  3. Clarity without frictionProduct and upgrade information that is clear, and never in the way.

03 · What I learned

Why people left the quote.

SourcesHotjar exit surveyCompetitor analysisPast experiments
Cognitive load

Several product tiers need several pages

→ One card per decision

Affect heuristic

Busy pages feel like risk

→ Cut to what changes the decision; tuck the rest away

Error recovery

People leave when they get stuck

→ Errors that say how to fix them

Social proof

Nobody knew the brand. Everyone knew Trustpilot.

→ Ratings right beside the price

04 · Speaking client-ese

Eight heroes, and the boring one won.

The brief was "forget the rules, throw some confetti in there." So I did, and made eight directions for the hero banner in a week.

Stakeholders loved the expressive ones. Then compliance reminded everyone that insurance is risk-averse. After a lively debate, we shipped the simplest one, highlighted below.

Hero exploration: pale illustration of a road curving through hills with trees
RoadCut
Hero exploration: light blue line-art mountains with a quote card
MountainsCut
Hero exploration: pale pink background with purple circle motifs
CirclesCut
Hero exploration: deep purple city skyline with a white quote card
CityCut
Hero exploration: deep purple with fine wave lines
WavesCut
Hero exploration: pale background with a grid of purple semicircles
GeometricCut
Hero exploration: angled purple panel with mountains, sun and a small car on a road
CarCut
Hero exploration: plain deep purple panel with the greeting and a quote card
PlainShipped
Stakeholders wantedConfetti. Illustration, scenery, personalization.
Compliance wantedNothing a regulator could read as frivolous.
What shippedA plain plum panel. All the energy moved into the price card, the row of trust signals and the copy.

What I learned is that when the page around it has to be quiet, the personality can go into the parts that do the persuading.

05 · What I decided

One decision per card, with the reviews right there.

This is the final journey. I made three structural decisions on the landing page, and added a set of small nudges on the pages after it.

The landing page as it shipped. The price card sits on the hero banner, the trust row is directly beneath it, and what the policy includes is an easy-to-scan list.FIG. 02

Simple stacked cards

The old page nested boxes inside boxes, so it was never clear what needed doing. One card per action made the next step obvious. It also cut development time, both for the build and for future test versions.

ShippedCognitive load

Reviews right where people hesitate

The row shows 93% of claims paid, a Trustpilot rating of 4.5 and four million policies. It sits immediately under the price, which is where someone decides whether to keep reading.

ShippedSocial proof

One platform, every product

The same set of components serves every product tier. Changing content means changing a setting.

ShippedGoal 2: one platform

The pages after the price

Add-ons people could actually compare.

After the landing page, the job was to make levels of cover easy to compare, and guide people to the one that fits.

Visual cuesBullet points with icons, so you can scan the difference between tiers instead of reading a paragraph.
RibbonsA "Most popular" label on the upgrade people actually choose. It's honest social proof.
Scenarios"Did you know 1 in 3 breakdowns happen at home?" A concrete picture of when the cover matters beats a feature list.
Plain exclusions"Not provided if your car is stolen or written off," marked clearly, so nobody discovers it at claim time.
Add-on cards: icons, a "Most popular" ribbon, a scenario and a visible exclusion.FIG. 03

The ribbons and the scenarios do the same job as the trust row. They give an anxious person something concrete to hold on to while they decide.

06 · What happened

Rolled out to half the traffic, then the phone rang.

The new journey went live to 50% of customers as an A/B test, while the other half still saw the old one. Sales rose enough that the client projected a five-year revenue figure from it while the eight-week test was still running.

Projected revenue

+£35m

The client's projection of revenue over five years, based on the sales increase measured in the A/B test. It's their number from their own model, and I've reported it as they did.

Add-on sales

10×

rise in sales of some add-ons, according to the client's digital manager.

Experimentation budget

2×

The client doubled their testing budget with us.

New business

Home

We were asked to design the first version of their home insurance journey.

At Conversion.com

Design of the Year

Awarded at Conversion.com's internal review, for the project's scope, complexity and client response.

Some of our ancillary sales are up by over 10x! Could we send you a fruit basket?Oliver Beadell · Digital Manager, 1st Central
You guys have been stars to work with. You'll be leading on the Home design, too, right?Paul Toppin · Head of Digital and Marketing, 1st Central
Happy devs. This has massively simplified the overall build!Craig Higgins · Senior Project Management Consultant, 1st Central

A 50/50 test over 8 weeks, measured on quote-to-policy conversion. The client modeled the increase as £35m over five years.

07 · Differently

What I’d do differently.

I'd have tested the trust row on its own. It went live inside a full redesign, so I can tell you the journey worked but not how much of it was the social proof. That is the question I most want the answer to.

I'd take "blue sky" less literally. Two heroes and a day-one chat with compliance would have bought time for the add-on pages, which is where the money turned out to be.

Next case study · Riot Games

Where the answer used to be a person.

Read the case study